Tuesday, September 16, 2008

graeters vs. aglamesis

ok, so this is probably really an overly discussed topic lately but i am an aglamesis fan. as i mentioned a few months ago, aglamesis is one of my happy places. i just go in there and feel completely calm and happy. i am crazy for their sundaes and the old school pink and white interior and the pretty candy displays.

(note for non-cincinnati readers: graeters and aglamesis are the two local ice cream chains which people argue over)

so of course i have always thought that i liked their ice cream better than graeters. however most people tell me that, in fact, it is NOT better, and that i am just being tricked by the sundaes (which, i don't care what you say, ARE better since you can get fresh whipped cream mixed with fruits and you just can't beat that).

at this point, i am confused and really do not know which i like better since... it is coconut ice cream month at graters. yay! i love coconut ice cream and i had some tonight and it was awesome. back in july i got some of their peach and that was delicious too.

my problem is that i hate chips/chunks/etc. in my ice cream, and that is like the graeters trademark. i think that might be my biggest problem with them. also they do not have a very good black cherry, and normally black cherry is my favorite flavor. well that or rum raisin, but that is pretty much a nonexistent flavor option here in cincinnati.

reader poll: which place do you like better? and is there some other secret yummy cincinnati ice cream that i'm missing out on?

10 comments:

Julie said...

Aglamesis. No question. I am not a chip-flavor girl. Give me Aglamesis any day. Aglamesis power!

Andrew said...

i like aglamesis' sundaes better. and their old timey oakley location is too cool.

Monkey said...

Putz's, no doubt- http://putzscreamywhip.com/ Simple, but so good. Especially their parfaits.
Between Graeter's and Aglamesis, I really don't have a fav. Graeter's has their apple cider sorbet now, so they're getting my business for the time being!

Anonymous said...

Did you see the story and video about Aglamesis in yesterday's paper?

http://news.cincinnati.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080917/ENT01/809170305

-Lauren the videographer (shamelessly self-promoting)

liz said...

oooh, putz's, i have always been meaning to check that out. i love soft serve!

yay re: the aglamesis article, i did not see that yesterday.

TD said...

Yeah... I hate the chips and chunks too. I thought I was the only person in Cincinnati who didn't like black raspberry chip!

I love Aglamesis but I like some of Graeter's other flavors (pumpkin, peach). So other than the chip issue, I'll take either.

WestEnder said...

black cherry w/ raspberry fudge topping, that is my sundae.

liberal foodie said...

graeter's because they're paying me to say this.

ok so they're not but I love them because of the big hunks of choc. chips in my black raspberry chip ice cream.

i haven't tried the sundaes at algamesis- so I can't say I don't like them yet but their ice cream doesn't have big hunks of chips in it.

Anonymous said...

Graeter's ice cream tastes better---Aglemesis is too icy...BUT, Aglemesis chocolate is better. BTW, I don't like the chips in the black raspberry either, so I called the factory and had them make a batch WITHOUT the chips----so good!

Claire said...

Agreed! Aglamesis is better.. Having had both within the past week, I can qualitatively say that aglamesis is better. Both are to be enjoyed, though! Claireeatstheworld.blogspot.com