Thursday, March 10, 2011

cincinnati is going down the toilet

i don't feel like food blogging anymore but that doesn't mean i feel like giving up my public megaphone. today i am going to bitch about how this city (and state) is a complete hell hole.

this week alone we have learned that cincinnati's population figures have (gasp) dropped 10%, just a week after mark mallory announced on undercover boss that "cincinnati is growing!" ummm, maybe should have checked your facts first. not only that, but unions are going the way of the betamax and apparently the streetcar funding is going to get sent back only to go to some other state where, you know, people might actually want something more out of life than living in isolation in the burbs with only gigantic televisions and high doses of antidepressants to keep them from a) suicide and b) having to actually interact with another human being. and on top of all that, forkheartknife is closing.

the last item might seem insignificant, but it's not. as a food lover, and an otr lover, and an always-trying-but-never-quite-succeeding cincinnati lover, i think it is just one illustration of the very big problem that we have in this city. people just don't give a fuck about other people (unless of course they went to high school with them).

tell me this isn't the most depressing thing you've ever read:
things feel pretty wild and crazy and we are starting to see lots of new customers who are finding out about us, making treks to OTR from who-knows-where. bringing with them expectations that we can’t and don’t want to meet. managing new customers and their expectations, managing long wait times: this is starting to feel overwhelming. our space is so intimate, the experience we offer is so giving of ourselves: our creativity, our emotion, our grieving, our energy. we are sharing all of this with a new kind of customer. one who doesn’t know that we are limited. one who doesn’t know that there is a long week of work going into just these four meals. one who doesn’t respect that we have opened and are maintaining a business (and a restaurant at that!)- we find it hard to rejuvenate after these meals. we are not getting the joy from our neighbors and friends and families (who decide not to wait, or take up a table) that made this place feel so magic. we can’t imagine another year of trying to make this tiny, ill-equiped, intimate space work . . .
do you know why they are closing? they are closing because there are just not enough other people like them in cincinnati. if there were, we would have other cozy, welcoming kitchens serving creative, wholesome, delicious food where we could go eat if it was too busy at forkheartknife and then they wouldn't be so overwhelmed. if there were, the suburban zombies wouldn't be suburban zombies and therefore wouldn't be driving an hour downtown on a quest to grasp some tiny feeling of connection via a lovingly cooked meal only to have a panic attack after having a HOMELESS PERSON!!! ask them for money while they shivered on the sidewalk (they didn't wear coats) waiting for a table.

these are the same people who don't want a streetcar and hate unions and thought that cincinnati was growing just because their subdivision razed a hundred more trees and threw down 20 more plots of land to build 20 more houses with 20 more 3 car garages for 20 more families just like theirs, not that they're going to actually interact with them other than sending them daily invites to play farmville on facebook.

i'm not even going to get into my usual rants about how this place treats immigrants like shit they just scraped off the bottom of their collective shoe (which went in and out of style five years ago everywhere else in the world), has no interest in learning or accepting anything about anyone who hasn't been here since their half german/half irish catholic ancestors came over on the mayflower, and has a population with an alarming number of people who have never even traveled to chicago (let alone outside of the country). not to mention that our state's superbowl (sorry, national championship) winning football coach is a national spectacle of hypocrisy and that nobody seems to give a fuck about whether some dude in warren county gets a fair trial (a fair trial? that sounds like socialism!).

in the name of tradition, family, and pseudo-christian morals the majority of cincinnatians run around in these isolationist bubbles of fear coated in insecurity wanting nothing more than to just. feel. safe. this drives them to compulsively live the exact same life as everybody else they know, with absolutely no interest in anyone else (unless, remember, you went to high school with them).

i tried to be optimistic for years but let's face it, it's never going to change. if you don't fit into a very specific demographic (white, moderate to conservative politically, christian, middle to upper class, and originally from cincinnati) or are not rich enough that nothing else matters, there's not much for you here, and it's only getting worse. most of the people who do fit that demographic are at best not doing anything to change things, and at worst doing everything in their power to keep it that way.

i'll admit that i'm feeling especially hateful right now but seriously, this place is a fucking joke on a stick. don't delude yourself with a new restaurant or a couple renovated buildings. if you're smart you'll get the hell out just like that 10% who already did. if you think there's any real hope you're only lying to yourself. and if you don't agree with me, you can... well, you know.

21 comments:

Sean Gray said...

I've been feeling the same way lately, Liz. Not sure I want to be here in a year.

Unknown said...

If you want to get out, lead the way. Some of us, despite the city's failings, would rather build it up than further tear it down. Cincinnati already has enough detractors without adding any more.

Yes Cincinnati's population is shrinking: welcome to the Midwest.

People act like assholes and are afraid of people not like them: welcome to everywhere in the world.

Yes, Forkheartknife is closing. I'm as sad as anyone about this. It is my favorite restaurant in Cincinnati and is a perfect representation of the vibrancy in OTR. They're quitting because they are too successful. That means that there is a market for good, simple food delivered with a smile and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Something will replace is.

If you want to be bitter and negative, fine. If you have more interest than being a defeatist than actually working to improve this city, fine. Just know that you are part of the problem, not the solution.

A.B. said...

Ok, I'll take you up on your challenge. It isn't the most depressing thing I've ever heard. Seriously, a good restaurant closing is supposed to be some horrific event? Come on. What it is on the scale of extremes is one of the most self-serving and whiny 'blog releases' I've ever read. They can't satisfy customers that can't deal with long wait times? They can only manage to serve four meals a week? Please. And I'm supposed to feel bad for them? If they really want to stay open they could have hired more staff so they can make more meals for the demanding public. Or they could move to a larger space. Instead they decided to close up shop and move on. There are plenty of restaurants downtown that serve quality food and find a way to manage. They could make changes to the way they operated their business, but they chose not to. That's fine, it's their right, but don't expect anyone to feel bad for them because they refuse to adjust their business model to meet the needs of the community.

haveanicedayv said...

There once was a little bird laying on his back with his feet in the air. When asked what he was doing, he replied: "I'm holding up the sky" which earned the rebuke: "What do you think you can do, with your spindly legs and little feet?" To that he said, "One does what one can."

While I share your dismay, acrimony and sometimes outrage, we need people with your passion and candor to continue to do what one can to help change the local environment, so don't leave.

Also, I like it when you blog from a place of anger, your imagery and word choice is hilarious...keep up the fight!

liz said...

josh, you don't know me, so there's no way for you to know this, but i have been in cincinnati almost five years and working exhaustively in every realm of my life to try to improve things in this city. professionally i am a legal aid attorney which means that i am getting paid shit to provide legal representation to people that most of cincinnati would rather pretend didn't exist. through my job i also participate in a few community organizations in several local counties. in my personal life, i volunteer regularly, and i also cofounded cincinnati imports, which is an organization that is meant to connect people who are not from cincinnati and people who are but just want to meet new people.

my bitterness and negativity is not just for spectacle, i'm too old for that. in fact, for years i was a cheerleader like you. but i have been worn down by watching my efforts have little to no impact on a large scale, and watching most people not even give a shit.

feel free to call me part of the problem if you like but i think some focused, well expressed rage every now and again is healthy and positive. and if your only response is to retreat into your cheerleader shell with a haughty "fine, we don't want you anyway," then you're part of the problem yourself.

Joe said...

I don't think the city's decline is due to German/Irish anti-foreigner bias. After all, this census shows the city as majority-minority. ...I live downtown, but my friends from east Asia & India all live in West Chester. The census bears out that the asian population in the suburbs is growing quickly. I don't think this is because West Chester is more progressive, but because it has pursued relatively good economic policies that make it a nice place to live. Economists tend to oppose higher taxes, big bureaucracies w/ strong unions, and lots of government intervention because they hurt long-run growth. Cincinnati has pursued such policies and not doing well. West Chester has not and is doing pretty well. It should be no surprise when companies move jobs out of the city.

Honestly, when I see the city govt increasing personnel expense by 20% over the last 2 years and spending so much time and money on maybe building a 3-mile streetcar with little apparent value, my first thought is to move to another city. Cincinnati is not serious about making the changes it needs to turn this slide around. So I worry about long-run opportunities here, and I don't want to pay for the city's stupid decisions as it falters. ...Anyway, that's my take.

liz said...

joe, thank you for a well articulated and intelligent counterpoint that is definitely worth consideration.

5chw4r7z said...

Wish I could give you a big >HUG< Liz. Sometimes I get all pissed off at the fear and stupidity, but I truly believe somewhere down the road people like us will out number the people who want to keep Cincinnati 20yrs behind the rest of the world and things will change.
Not gonna argue it, I have to believe it to keep going.

prolix21 said...

I've gotta admit that I often feel this way and have to bite my tongue a lot in public and on my own blog.

You're not alone in your frustrations. It's definitely a tough time to be positive with so much negative going on in this country, this state and I often feel like most of the city is against us when it comes to things like streetcars, downtown and OTR.

With that said, I don't regret moving to OTR, buying a condo there or being there. There are certainly a lot of things going on now to make everyone wonder if the progress we have made will be short lived. Grammers, ForkHeart, the endless closures of the Relish Group, etc. On the flip side there while we're watching some of our favorites close, new places are opening and slated to open. OTR specifically is young in its rebirth and it's going to be dynamic and full of openings and closures.

Love them or hate them, 3CDC is a force in our community and I don't see them turning away, in fact it seems like they are picking up momentum. We may not all agree on the specifics, but they're a force and they want OTR and Cincinnati to succeed as much as any of us.

So while our state and local government may be a total joke, there are others who are moving forward without them. Tons more condo's are opening, more rentals and the Banks only adds to that. The population will grow, it just takes time. The last sensus was before the riots, the latest was after. We're still recovering from that population exodus.

Another thing that often turns my mood is other people in OTR. Last night at the Yelp event we again met more OTR neighbors who love it, and while we can all admit it's not perfect, it's still a great place to live and there's always something new around the bend.

Maria G. said...

I can definitely share in your frustration. It feels like Cincinnati is on the verge of moving forward, but bad attitudes and terrible elected officials are doing all they can to prevent it.

This was a good, venting blog post. I'm not 100% in agreement, but you've definitely given a voice to some unpleasant feelings I've been harboring lately. I hope you do stick around-through your work and your volunteering, and your strong opinions, you are a big asset to the city. We could use more people like you.

Thanks for the food for thought.

Unknown said...

Liz,

I never presumed to know you or what you do. It's great that you work at Legal Aid; your work is important and, frankly, I wish there were more of you. I, too, work for a social service agency and it's likely that I've been in the room with you and even talked to you in the past.

I understand the outrage. I'm outraged almost every single day by the things I see in this city and in this state. I'm weary of it often, but I still have too much hope for what CAN happen here. I'm not saying it will, but I can guarantee it won't happen if people decide it can't.

I didn't mean what I said as a dig at you and perhaps I was too strong with my wording. I definitely don't want you (or anyone else) excluded from anything in this city. It just makes me sad to see a young person who is making a difference (no matter how small) in the community and who has such passion become so pessimistic. Pessimism is the enemy to progress in any city, Cincinnati not excluded.

If you would ever like to grab a drink and air grievances or like a chance to rant, I'd be happy to grab a drink sometime. I can always do with knowing another person at Legal Aid.

Unknown said...

Liz, I'm sorry to say but I completely agree with Josh. while it is understandable that you seem to be surrounded by defeat from all sides (& from your comment about your job, it sounds like this is just as much a personal issue, as a Cincinnati thing), and YES, angry rants can be helpful, this is the kind of self-defeatist talk that creates a negative/small-minded Cincinnati.
I personally want to be a part of the solution.
from Forkheartknife's own blog post, they were "ill equipped" to handle their success. their future and the rest of the city's remains bright--despite the change in plans.
please use your voice to uplift and not degrade my town. up until now I have been a happy reader of your blog. I'm not sure how that will continue if you use this platform to tear down my city.

liz said...

bob, you are someone who continually impresses me in terms of your ability to be optimistic. i wish i had your positivity.

josh, i appreciate your response and i'm definitely up for grabbing a drink sometime to talk more.

maria #2, this is most definitely a very personal issue. sorry if you're not a happy reader of my blog anymore, but that's the reason i posted this. i wanted to piss people off. there are plenty of other blogs out there for you to read if you're looking for content that's more guided by a desire for popularity than confrontation with real feelings and issues.

Anonymous said...

I've always agreed with those who view Cincinnati as not so much a city, but a collection of feudal neighborhoods and micro-neighborhoods.

My enthusiasm about the "pro-city, I love my town, rah-rah Go Cincy" crowd has taken a similar path to yours. It now seems to be a largely "go-OTR, I love the CBD, rah-rah why are these Hyde Park aushlanders in my way at Lackman's" crowd. They're engaging in the same provincial behavior as everyone else.

Maybe it's the hills, the roads, or the natives inability to drive on them in any kind of weather, but no amount of cheerleading has fixed the neighborhood separation anxiety mindset yet.

I could not agree more with your razor sharp point that a city of this size should have a better ratio of cozy, creative, welcoming restaurants to residents.

It just seems that there are a lot of loud, dumb assholes in Cincinnati, they have too much power and people pay way too much attention to them or don't care enough to stop them from getting their way.

Becky said...

Liz -

I grew up in this area and for many reasons that I won't go into I feel stuck here until some things change. There are a handful of other cities that I'd rather live in besides Cincinnati.

Just curious though, what is it about Cincinnati that keeps you here?

liz said...

1. i would have to take the bar again if i moved somewhere else
2. my goal is to pay off all my credit card debt before taking on the expense of moving
3. i'm lazy
4. moving sucks

Becky said...

I can sympathize with you on the moving. I hope something turns around for you soon.

ange said...

On my bad days, especially when it's cloudy for the 400th day in the endless Ohio winter, I feel exactly the same way. I just moved back to Cincy from Denver and it's been quite the shock.

But... maybe if us like-minded folk keep banding together and don't give up, we can finally overthrow the backwardness!

As a public interest attorney myself, I totally relate with the frustration (and sometimes I think we of all people just start to feel barraged by the mess of social problems since we deal with it at work all day, too).

So, don't move. Taking another bar sucks, trust me. Moving sucks, too. :) Hope to run into you sometime.

Take care!

mytincart said...

@liz: I agree that Republican and Tea Party directives will always aim to keep Cincinnati in the stone age. Anything that amounts to any kind of progress in this or any city seems to be thanks to far more forward thinking than either of the above have the ability to conceive right now.

It wasn't always that way: Reagan promoted labor unions. I don't know what has changed other than the advent of gasbags like Glenn Beck and Rush Limbaugh driving the Republican party's post-9/11 brain sucking initiative.

@Joe: Just because "economists" oppose labor unions doesn't make the stripping of worker rights a just cause. Thanks to our new governor Kasich, my brother and his wife --both teachers-- have been told they risk having their salaries each cut by $15k. They are now worried about keeping up with their mortgage on an $85,000 house.

My mother, who works for the state government, is now being forced into early retirement lest she lose a large chunk of her benefits. And oh, did I mention she filed for bankruptcy?

These talking points might sound great to you and to Glenn Beck and to Rush, but it's quite another thing when the consequences affect someone you care about.

mrs.krause.english said...

Sometimes I feel the same way. Then I read your blog and remember that there are people who get frustrated by the same things that frustrate me. And someday we'll win.

sybil law said...

Please don't leave. I've just found your blog! We're not all assholes. Promise. :)